neo_aish
Idol-wannabe
God Apprentice
onaka suita~ *w*
Posts: 21
|
Post by neo_aish on Mar 9, 2004 14:26:06 GMT -5
[glow=blue,2,300]I have a question.... I was arguing? not really..discussing what does doujinshi exactly means...>_>;;in go-gaia...(for that i'm leaving go-gaia soon...) neo_aish can't take defeat that well...T_T and so..I yahoo and google it...and found this... en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doujinshifrom what it looks...it's a fanart..fan fic...no matter you add original chara or so..it'll still be doujinshi if some elements of diff work is present....even if it's your old work.... *..i can't ask dad...coz..dad is an old japanese..and is not familiar with the term doujinshi* and so the discussion was... can anyone tell me...is small published manga by a beginner or amateur is called doujinshi...or just manga by amateur?because someone told me...it is called doujinshi even if it's your own 100% original work....T_T.....*is confused* 3.30 am...gotta sleep [/glow]
|
|
|
Post by BNA on Mar 10, 2004 6:16:48 GMT -5
the description is ok to me see you on sunday Neo
|
|
|
Post by Aki on Mar 10, 2004 12:06:59 GMT -5
[glow=blue,4,300] A doujinshi is basically a form of Fan Art, one that is based on existing series though there can be a mix of based and original characters and even crossings between different series.
Basically, in Japan, doujinshi are made by either fans and/or the Mangaka itself. It usually shows the story in a different point of view, a different storyline which deviates from the original and so on.
A note of interest is that people who write and draw doujinshi do not need to ask permission from the Mangaka and/or its publishing house. If someone loves a series so much to create a DJ out of it, then that's what they do and is considered extremely flattering.
If the work is 100% original then no, it is NOT a doujinshi but an original work from an amateur Mangaka. The term "amateur" refers only to the fact that said Mangaka is still very little known and has not yet published in the more reknown magasines.
Hope this answered the question a bit and that it wasn't too confusing. ;D
Anyflip, that is what is refered to as a Doujinshi in Japan. (Yep! I asked Koi! lol) [/glow]
|
|
neo_aish
Idol-wannabe
God Apprentice
onaka suita~ *w*
Posts: 21
|
Post by neo_aish on Mar 10, 2004 14:19:57 GMT -5
sankyu~~aki san~~~~T_T i linked the same url...still the girl insist that amateur manga is doujinshi...and furthermore...she said MANGA is NOT A MANGA if it was NOT WRITTEN by a JAPANESE...sorry for the caps...*a little angry coz of hirose and the girl*....
|
|
|
Post by Aki on Mar 10, 2004 19:58:13 GMT -5
Oh you're kidding, right? LOL That's too priceless! Actually, the term that everyone use, 'manga', has become the norm to refer to a Japanese comic book.
Nevertheless, in actuality, 'manga' is but a word. 'Comic', 'comic book', 'comic strip', that's what 'manga' means so, in Japan, anyone be they Japanese or not, is a mangaka if what they do is draw comic strips and/or books! To them, Marvel and DC, all those American comic books are also manga! It's the word they use for a comic book of any style!
In the end, everything that is a comic from any countries are all manga is one goes by the true meaning of the word.
*sighs* Some really should get to learn a bit more about the Japanese culture before making such claims, darou?[/color]
|
|
neo_aish
Idol-wannabe
God Apprentice
onaka suita~ *w*
Posts: 21
|
Post by neo_aish on Mar 11, 2004 3:43:04 GMT -5
hai~ feels better but...still leaving gaia ^_^;;;..... yume chapter 4..is....a lil hard to trans..>_> better split it..>_>;;;;.....gomen minasan~
|
|
|
Post by BNA on Mar 11, 2004 7:51:17 GMT -5
urgh Aki is right, gomen nasai >.> didn't read it all >_<# /me feels so very stupid btw London is a great city, but hum with today's events in Spain it's kind of weird, you know... All these ppl killed by the bombs in the trains... it's scary. Guess here too, they'll reinforce security. Today, we're going to visit London tower -lol- well hrrrrr if we can ok I'm off, gonna go dinner see you sunday
|
|
neo_aish
Idol-wannabe
God Apprentice
onaka suita~ *w*
Posts: 21
|
Post by neo_aish on Mar 14, 2004 11:48:47 GMT -5
it's monday here...T_T...and yet haven't started ch 4..*hits her head*....T_T....
|
|